Don’t Confuse FIRE With Fire
Don’t Confuse FIRE With Fire
I love the FIRE (Financial Independence/Retire Early) acronym. Not only does it capture everything in just four letters, the imagery is stunning. The passion and flames of financial independence burn inside of us. This is not the movement for the bland, uninsightful, or cold. We are hot-blooded individuals who bring the heat to everyday life. We are purposeful. But if you take the metaphor a little farther, things start to break down. Fires can be quenched, flames die out. There is an insidious risk in the financial independence community. Many of us confuse our goal post with our post or even pre goal plan. We confuse FIRE with fire.
Now that I’ve completely lost you, let’s dive in.
What is FIRE?
FIRE is a superpower. It’s a mindset. It’s the idea that through careful earning, saving, and investing we can reach a place of not only financial security but also freedom. Although many disagree about what constitutes enough, we mostly point to the safe withdrawal rate and the 25X rule as guide posts.
Once we have obtained enough, we can live out the second part of the equation: retire early. Early retirement looks very different to all of us. A subset decide to continue their W2 wage but cut back on hours. Others leave their formal employment but continue with side hustles like blogs or real estate. A third group abandons the accumulation phase altogether.
For the grand majority, FIRE unto itself should not be the goal. It should be a means to an end. A means to traveling, or pursuing a hobby, or spending time with loved ones. In this mindset, money is a proxy for time. Time has value. We have bought our freedom.
There are those who have made the pursuit of FIRE their passion. Mr Money Mustache or Brad and Jonathan come to mind.
For the rest of us, however, being too enamored with the journey leads on a long path to nowhere.
Don’t confuse FIRE with fire.
What is fire?
Fire is your passion. It is your why. It is your reason for waking up every morning. This passion can change throughout our lives. As a child and young adult, I thought being a physician was my fire. Growing older, I find that writing has quickly overtaken its place.
Whether your family, your friends, or surf boarding, the exact details are unimportant. What is important, however, is that you have inspiration. You have a goal that is out there just waiting to be reached. The striving towards something, the reaching for unobtainable heights, is the stuff that contentment is made of.
When you confuse FIRE with fire, you set yourself up for depression. This is the slippery slope of the money mind meld. There is nothing more jarring than reaching the top of the mountain and realizing that there is nowhere to go but down.
And most of us don’t want to go down.
Final Thoughts
When we make FIRE our goal, we set ourselves up for a dysphoric conclusion to our journey. You must not confuse FIRE with fire.
Financial independence should be Plan B, a happy side effect of pursuing passion and the ever-present light inside.
Your FIRE journey will end when you reach a certain number.
Your fire journey should last a lifetime.
So. Well. Said.
Thanks Amy. Your comment made my day!
Money is a tool that buys options. Without desire for an option what do you have? A bridge to nowhere. Very well stated post.
Thanks FTF. I like the bridge to nowhere metaphor. It sums up the post nicely.
A cool post, I love how the FIRE community consists of lots of people from random backgrounds with a real fire about them. It’s awesome.
Although there is a subset that troubles me, people who want to do the least possible for the maximum gain and screw everyone else.
Hopefully that subset is small.
Agree! Interesting Post!
If we fixate on that goal post of FIRE; we will surely miss out on what’s taking place on the field.
And the field itself……. legendary. Let’s just say, I have the greatest respect for all the fields, in their many forms.
The field is important. Let’s not miss it.
Wow, great post. Just when I thought you were going to talk about one thing, you threw a curve ball at me that I didn’t see coming.
From reading the title, I immediately thought “FIRE = good and fire = bad (dangerous)”, so let’s see what he says. But instead, you eloquently discuss the passion and fire within us.
A totally unexpected, yet pleasant surprise. And a joy to read too. A perfect example of “Personal Finance with a twist”!
You have a beautiful way with words.
It’s that twist thing again.😛
This is awesome…. most of us often make that mistake. We confuse the goal of hitting FIRE with purpose. FI should never be what defines us, it should be the byproduct of us living intentionally and going after our dreams.
Always on point Doc!
A byproduct, a side effect. A plan B.
The strange thing I’ve found is that now that I’ve slightly early retired with way over my 25x the side gigs I set up as entertainment are actually making so much money I don’t need my investments. I haven’t touched them in the 3 years since I left my career. And I’m happy with our lifestyle so it seems insane to inflate our spending just because we can. I don’t think I’m alone in this either. Someone who was happy living on 25% of their former income can possibly earn that much working only one day a week, that’s what has happened to us.
An enviable position, I’d say.
We definitely see eye to eye. Lot of people want to FIRE just to leave a job they don’t want but if there is nothing that they are passionate about they will lose self-identity/social interactions that they got from work and be miserable at home. I few months ago I honestly did not know what I would do with the time if I was able to walk away from work. Yes I would travel (that may take several months out of the year) but what about the remaining? Happy to find blogging as a great diversion that has renewed my passion. I forgot how fun creative writing was and by comments left by others you also don’t give up social interaction if and when you leave the workforce.
I think writing is a great Post FIRE activity. It certainly keeps me thinking.
My experience at the end of FIRE was not Fire. It was freedom. It is Zen. It is Creative Destruction. It’s disruptive. It’s an existence of being and not of doing. Fire implies kinetics with its concomitant consumption and exhaustion. My experience is potential, actualization and peace.
Interesting. I think when at the beginning of your career, you are much more caught up on doing. As time passes, being becomes more of a priority.
FIRE is freedom. And I sometimes paint half my face blue an run around with a sword yelling it.
Ok Mel!
I was going to write my own comment, but I cannot possibly improve on this one. Can I borrow a sword, or do I need to fork out the cash for one?
Great post, can’t agree more with you. If you aren’t happy now, reaching FIRE isn’t going to magically make you happy. It’s all about having the passion and making your life better every day.
Yes, incrementally moving towards better. The Why of FI is just as important as the how or when.
I appreciate you (and others before) who’ve touched on this subject. I keep a notebook handy of “what do I want to do” and “why” now in addition to all the spreadsheets as the time of change is approaching. I’m amazed at the number of people who’ve advised about needing a long detox period for everything to soak in, both in the FIRE community and elsewhere. A former boss of mine who retired 13 years before the traditional age said to me “It takes months to realize the amount of BS you’ve been programmed to put up with for a decade or more…and that you no longer have to”.
I wonder if you can continuously detox and wind down work at the same time. So that when you get to RE, you are already ready.
FIRE without Fire is not a good thing. I know few folks who could FIRE but don’t choose to because they have no idea what to do next, they haven’t found their ‘fire’ just yet. Great post.
RE is a big step if you do not have some sort of purpose outside FI. Some people just work forever.